Mission: Elfpossible game night: food, drinks and music

Put on your favorite holiday music and make a mug of hot chocolate before you start Mission: Elfpossible. The recipes below range from a quick snack to a whole spread, so you can keep the preparation as small as you like.

 

  

Your own holiday favorites are a good place to start. We also put together a holiday adventure playlist to play in the background while you solve. Keep it quiet enough to hear each other.

Homemade hot chocolate takes a little more effort than opening a packet, and you can adjust it to your taste. Start with this hot chocolate recipe, then set out a few toppings so everyone can choose their own.

Eggnog

You can buy eggnog ready-made or try this homemade eggnog recipe. Make it ahead of time and chill it until you’re ready to play. 

Hot cider is a good choice if you’d prefer fruit and spice to another creamy drink. Follow this cider recipe and serve it warm, with alcohol added to individual mugs if wanted.

Sugar cookies are the ones to choose if decorating is part of the evening. Bring out the cookie cutters and sprinkles before the game. This sugar cookie recipe and this holiday version both include frosting recipes.

Peppermint bark

Peppermint bark needs crushed candy canes and layers of dark and white chocolate. Make it ahead so it has time to set. You can serve some during the game and wrap the rest as gifts. 

Popcorn

Popcorn is easy to share. Start with stovetop popcorn, then try Christmas Crunch or gingerbread caramel for something sweet. For a savory bowl, there’s garlic herb or Parmesan ranch. These other popcorn variations give you more options.

 

Roasted nuts

You can make roasted chestnuts in the oven without an open fire. For a different mix, try maple rosemary roasted nuts. Serve either in small bowls beside the game.

 

Cranberry brie bites

These cranberry brie bites combine puff pastry with brie, cranberries, pecans and rosemary. They’re small enough to eat between puzzles, though it’s best to keep the serving tray away from your keyboard.

 

Pigs in a blanket wreath

This pigs in a blanket wreath doubles as a centerpiece. The recipe makes 24 bites, so it’s a useful choice when you’re feeding a group.

 

More ideas